EU court revives approval of KLM's €3.4bn Covid aid

The EU's top court set aside a 2024 ruling that annulled approval of €3.4bn in Dutch Covid aid to KLM, dismissing part of Ryanair's challenge. The rest of the case returns to the General Court, and Ryanair also lost a related Condor case.

Share
EU court revives approval of KLM's €3.4bn Covid aid
Photo by Isaac Struna / Unsplash

All figures are in euros unless stated. €1 = $1.1143.

The European Court of Justice on November 5 set aside a 2024 ruling that had annulled the European Commission's approval of €3.4bn of Dutch state aid to KLM during the pandemic, handing a partial defeat to Ryanair, which brought the original challenge. The court dismissed part of Ryanair's case and sent its remaining arguments back to the lower General Court, so the dispute is not yet over.

The aid, a state loan and a state guarantee on bank loans granted in 2020, has a long legal history. The General Court first annulled the Commission's approval for inadequate reasoning, after which the Commission adopted a new decision naming KLM and its subsidiaries as the only beneficiaries, and the General Court annulled that decision in February 2024 on the grounds that Air France and the Air France-KLM holding company should also have been treated as beneficiaries.

The Court of Justice found that the General Court had used the right legal test, known as the economic unit concept, which asks whether related companies operate as a single business, but had applied it wrongly. It said the lower court had reweighed the evidence without showing that the Commission's conclusion was implausible or manifestly wrong, so the Commission's finding that Air France and KLM retained considerable economic autonomy stands.

Air France-KLM described the ruling as favourable and said all its Covid-19 support had been repaid with interest by 2023. The group said it would continue to defend its interests as the case returns to the General Court, which must now decide Ryanair's other arguments in line with the higher court's judgment.

Ryanair also lost a related case the same day, when the Court of Justice ruled against it over €321mn of German aid granted to Condor in 2021, according to Reuters. The airline has brought more than a dozen challenges against the state support that European governments gave to rival carriers during the pandemic.

The rulings matter beyond KLM, because they define how far courts will second-guess the Commission's judgment about which companies within an airline group benefit from state support. That question is likely to recur as governments weigh support for weaker carriers during the current fuel shock, and as state-owned airlines such as TAP Air Portugal pass into private groups.

What to watch: how quickly the General Court rules on Ryanair's remaining arguments, whether Ryanair pursues further challenges to pandemic-era aid, and how the Commission applies the economic unit test to any new state support for airlines.